As video game developers, we know how important it is to ensure our games are of high quality. But what about the grading process? How do we make sure our games are graded accurately and fairly? In this guide, we will explore the different options available for getting a video game graded, as well as best practices and tips for success.
What is Video Game Grading?
Before we dive into the specifics of how to get a video game graded, let’s first define what we mean by “graded.” Simply put, video game grading involves evaluating the quality of a game and assigning it a score based on various criteria. This score can be used to determine eligibility for awards, recognition, or even funding opportunities.
Option 1: Professional Grading Organizations
Professional grading organizations, such as the Entertainment Software Rating Board (ESRB) or the Gamespot Review System, are one of the most common ways to get a video game graded. These organizations use a set of criteria to evaluate games and assign them a score out of 10 or 100.
The main advantage of using a professional grading organization is that they have a large pool of experienced evaluators who can provide objective, unbiased feedback on the quality of a game. Additionally, these organizations typically have strict guidelines for evaluating games, which helps ensure consistency and fairness in the grading process.
However, there are also some disadvantages to using a professional grading organization. For one, the cost of getting a game graded can be relatively high, especially if you’re looking for an in-depth review. Additionally, these organizations may not have the same level of expertise or specialized knowledge as other types of evaluators, which could lead to inaccurate or misleading scores.
Option 2: User Reviews and Ratings
User reviews and ratings are another way to get a video game graded. These can come from various sources, such as online review sites, social media platforms, or even word-of-mouth recommendations.
The main advantage of user reviews and ratings is that they provide real-world feedback from people who have actually played the game. This can be especially valuable for indie developers who may not have the resources to hire professional evaluators. Additionally, user reviews can help build buzz and generate interest in a game, which can be particularly important during the launch phase.
However, there are also some disadvantages to relying on user reviews and ratings. For one, these scores can be highly subjective and may not necessarily reflect the quality of the game itself. Additionally, user reviews may be influenced by factors such as personal bias or gaming platform, which could lead to inconsistent or inaccurate scores.
Option 3: Expert Evaluations
Expert evaluations involve having a professional reviewer or critic evaluate a game and provide feedback based on their expertise and experience. This can include industry professionals such as game designers, journalists, or critics from reputable publications.
The main advantage of expert evaluations is that they provide a high level of specialized knowledge and expertise. This can be particularly valuable for games that are aimed at a niche audience or require a deep understanding of complex game mechanics. Additionally, expert evaluations can help build credibility and establish a game’s reputation within the industry.
However, there are also some disadvantages to relying on expert evaluations. For one, these scores can be highly subjective and may not necessarily reflect the overall quality of the game. Additionally, finding an expert reviewer who is available and willing to evaluate a game can be difficult, especially for smaller or indie studios.
